The Monterey Hotel
A historic downtown Monterey hotel with Victorian furnishings, in-room fireplaces, and easy access to Fisherman's Wharf.
The verdict
Pick a traveller type to re-weight the scores and re-rank the rooms around what you actually care about.
The Monterey Hotel offers a downtown stay featuring Victorian furnishings and cozy in-room fireplaces. Guests appreciate the friendly registration desk staff and comfortable beds, along with easy access to dining and the bay. However, thin walls mean guestrooms are not soundproof, leaving conversations easily audible from neighboring areas. 1916918
Every line below traces back to something a traveler actually wrote — open a line to read the original sentence and follow it to the source.
What travelers noticed
- Guests consistently praise the welcoming staff at the registration desk and the prompt valet parking service. 9
- The beds and pillows are widely noted for offering a comfortable night of rest. 161018
- Rooms with fireplaces and warm Victorian decor create a cozy atmosphere for relaxing after a day of sightseeing. drawn from the full read
The catch
Who it's for
- — Walkers exploring Fisherman's Wharf
- — Guests wanting in-room fireplaces
- — Travelers seeking classic Victorian decor
Skip it if
- — Light sleepers sensitive to thin walls
- — Guests needing spacious bathroom counters
- — Anyone expecting included breakfast
Seen on camera
21 moments · 4 videos · The Monterey Hotel
Each moment is pulled at the second a cited reviewer said the words. Play it here, or open the original video at that timestamp.
“the bathroom is small but functional there isn't a lot of counter space so make sure you plan accordingly if you bring a…”
youtube.com3:01“there's my robe from the spa really nice robes”
youtube.com1:49“got my card oh yeah check this out guys this room is so cool so cool oh look at that it's quiet now”
youtube.com6:01“I just checked the room prices for this hotel 160 to 399 for a premium room which is not bad for Monterey guys for the o…”
youtube.com24:24“now they do have elevators and they do have steps as well so you don't necessarily have to take the elevators nice some…”
youtube.com25:26“and then down there that is the shooter's restaurant on site very delicious a little water fountain there”
youtube.com3:20“upon entering the hotel's main lobby you're greeted by the friendly faces of the wonderful staff at the registration des…”
youtube.com0:28“and then of course the shower shower is super important to all of us you want to have the space you want to have a nice…”
youtube.com1:54“on the balcony you'll find two chairs and a small table and great views of the hammock Garden where you can Lounge in on…”
youtube.com3:30“awesome I got some water it's always nice when they Supply water not every place does”
youtube.com2:46“and yeah right off of community Road perfect location it's all about the location right guys”
youtube.com3:28“The hotel features 80 well-appointed rooms, each meticulously designed to ensure you have a cozy sanctuary to return to…”
youtube.com0:35“Plus, with complimentary high-speed Wi-Fi throughout the property, you can easily share your coastal photos or stay conn…”
youtube.com1:41“At the Red Lion Hotel Monterey, we combine attentive service with a comfortable, inviting atmosphere to ensure your stay…”
youtube.com1:49“it's so nice man I think it's the sound of the ocean right there and not only that guys if you get an ocean view room yo…”
youtube.com30:16“one of the highlights of the hotel is the sea Roots breakfast buffet featuring a juicer where you make your own juice in…”
youtube.com0:59“the room is well appointed with two queen beds a television a chair in the corner and a fan on the ceiling”
youtube.com3:16“here you have your fridge let's see oh decent sized fridge shelves there are pretty shallow but that is decent size you…”
youtube.com2:27“look at that this view hold on hold on hold on look at this View that is so cool guys”
youtube.com7:14“unfortunately this is the only Hotel I stayed in Monterey actually I've stayed in another one but this one you cannot be…”
youtube.com9:28“Whether you are traveling for a much-needed vacation or a professional business trip, this three-star gem serves as the…”
youtube.com0:21Frames are citations: each one links to its second in the source video, attributed to the creator who filmed it. Nothing here is supplied by the hotel. Creators who want a moment removed can ask and we take it down.
How to book
No loyalty currency of its own — this one is a cash or card-portal booking.
Score breakdown
How the 74/100 is built, category by category — each one with the strongest thing travelers actually said, and the source it came from.
Bathroom
84Food
93Location
93Noise
85- “it's so nice man I think it's the sound of the ocean right there and not only that guys if you get an ocean view room you can literally hear hopefully you're not like a you know light sleep or whatever but you can hear the ocean waves all night it is so nice so nice” 2130:16
- “Couples looking for quiet relaxation may want to look elsewhere, as weekends can get loud with families here enjoying the pools and outdoor activities.” 19
Room
74- “The room was clean and comfortable, the décor warm and charming, and the bed and pillows very comfortable.” 18
- “Cozy up in style with our Deluxe King Suite, a spacious retreat designed for ultimate relaxation. Perfect for two guests, this elegant suite features a plush king-size bed, refined décor, and plenty of extra space to unwind.” 16
Service
84Bed & Sleep
74Where it is, how to reach it
Details checked 2026-09-13
Where it sits
The Monterey Hotel and the 19 other hotels we cover in Monterey. Hover a marker for the hotel; click to open it.
Stay value
How this property reads against the hotels we cover alongside it. Measured on review evidence, not on a nightly rate.
Falls short of what $ usually buys
Scores 8 points below the modest median of 82, across 516 hotels in the same bracket. In Monterey it sits 9 points below the local median of 83.
- This hotel
- 74
- Bracket median
- 82
- Index median
- 86
Based on 516 comparable hotels.
Which room to ask for
What reviewers say about where to sleep inside this building — by room number where one is named, and otherwise by floor, wing, aspect and position. Every line opens onto the quotes behind it.
- 5 mentions
No location within the hotel draws repeated complaints yet.
Where travelers agree — and don’t
The topics reviewers split on most. A wide bar means your experience depends on which room you get — or whose opinion you trust.
View the 82 things travelers said behind this verdict▾
Quotes run exactly as travelers wrote them — spelling and all. We trim for length, never for tidiness.
- “The staff is kind and accommodating, and the off-season prices are very good.” 18
- “The prices, I thought, were reasonable because the room was large and elegant, the staff friendly, and there was free parking.” 2
- “The on-site restaurant, Tusca, is sophisticated but overpriced, but Knuckles sports bar is popular even with locals.” 10
- “High resort fee for Wi-Fi and parking” 10
- “Note that the hotel tacks on a hefty per-night resort fee to cover parking, in-room Wi-Fi, business center use, access to the outdoor games, and a host of other minor services.” 10
- “Prices certainly weren't the worst I've seen at hotels, and while it might not be the same caliber of California fare getting served up the road at Chez Panisse or The French Laundry, Sea Root was certainly tasty and popular with guests.” 19
- “Neither of these hotels is within walking distance of the Monterey sights. You have to drive a short distance and then park, which is an expensive nuisance.” 2
- “I just checked the room prices for this hotel 160 to 399 for a premium room which is not bad for Monterey guys for the ocean view and the restaurant A Bar happy hour” On camera2124:24
- “From outdoor pools and fire pits to golf course views and kid-friendly amenities, the Hyatt Regency Monterey Hotel and Spa on Del Monte Golf Course offers great value, especially when booked with World of Hyatt points.” 17
- “Popular sports bar and good (but expensive) restaurant on-site” 10
- “Pricey but well-equipped, the spa covers two floors with treatment rooms and relaxation spaces.” 10
- “Cash rate was $445.61 per night which equals to 2.96 cents per point, an outstanding value!” 17
- “unfortunately this is the only Hotel I stayed in Monterey actually I've stayed in another one but this one you cannot beat a beachfront hotel for the price” On camera219:28
- “I had high expectations for this being a tribute hotel but I left this morning feeling like I stayed at an econobox that cost a fraction of the price.” 5
- “Admittedly, this hotel can sometimes reach that price point, but I've also seen rates as low as $300 per night, depending on the season, which feels reasonable for what you get.” 3
- “3rd floor beach view room that while had a beautiful view our room was very disappointing.” 5
- “The décor is coastal yet contemporary, with cozy touches like fireplaces in the social spaces and window-side lounge areas in the rooms that center around enjoying the nature just outside.” 3
- “Cozy up in style with our Deluxe King Suite, a spacious retreat designed for ultimate relaxation. Perfect for two guests, this elegant suite features a plush king-size bed, refined décor, and plenty of extra space to unwind.” 16
- “The Historic Two Queen Suite offers a perfect blend of Victorian charm and modern comfort. With two plush queen-size beds, hand-carved wood furnishings, antique décor, plantation shutters, and ceiling fans, this suite exudes timeless elegance.” 16
- “got my card oh yeah check this out guys this room is so cool so cool oh look at that it's quiet now” On camera216:01
- “on the balcony you'll find two chairs and a small table and great views of the hammock Garden where you can Lounge in one of several hammocks or play on the rope swing” On camera93:30
- “We were delighted at check-in to be upgraded to a relatively spacious (685 sq. ft) Monterey Suite with One King Bed, a living room with a sleeper sofa, and two bathrooms.” 17
- “The room was clean and comfortable, the décor warm and charming, and the bed and pillows very comfortable.” 18
- “the room is well appointed with two queen beds a television a chair in the corner and a fan on the ceiling” On camera93:16
- “Further, the bathrooms were a bit inconsistent (though still sufficient and functional) in that the bathroom off the bedroom was more modern - with a walk-in, glass-walled shower - than the tub-and-curtain setup in the bathroom on the living room side of the suite.” 19
- “all right I also want to show you this guys so coming from the room turn the lights off so you get like a more of a view check this out look at that Heaven man cannot beat this this is so nice” 21
- “The bedroom setup featured plenty of built-in electrical outlets on each nightstand. There was ample space to stretch out in the suite, and blackout shades made sleep easy at night.” 19
- “It is a delightful experience as the car was always waiting for us when we needed it. We booked a king room in the recently redone part of the hotel, and it was a large, spacious room complete with a bed, couch, and fireplace.” 8
- “I stayed in a Premium King room with ocean views and loved how spacious the bedroom area felt.” 3
- “A perfect blend of elegance and relaxation, our Deluxe Queen room welcomes up to two guests. With plush bedding and refined décor, it's a cozy retreat after a day of exploring nearby attractions like Cannery Row, Fisherman's Wharf, and the breathtaking coastline-all within walking distance.” 16
- “Golfers come for the bragging rights; everyone else comes for the pools, hammock gardens, and convenient location near the world-famous Monterey Bay Aquarium.” 7
- “Perfectly positioned in downtown Monterey, The Monterey Hotel places guests steps from The Monterey Conference Center, the weekly Tuesday Farmers Market, and local dining and shopping.” 16
- “Convenient location a short drive to Monterey attractions and restaurants” 10
- “The location was perfect for walking to the Wharf, Cannery Row, and great restaurants.” 18
- “The hotel proved to be an excellent spot for exploring the Monterey area as you could easily walk to Fisherman's Wharf for restaurants like LouLou's Griddle in the Middle and the Old Fisherman's Grotto.” 8
- “Due to California's strict coastal regulations and permitting process, new properties this close to the ocean are rare, making Monterey Beach Hotel's oceanfront setting a rarity in a region that's all about enjoying the stunning coastline.” 3
- “We plan on staying again. This hotel is located in a perfect spot, with plenty of amazing restaurants within a very short walking distance.” 18
- “That said, the hotel is about a five-minute drive from downtown Monterey, in the neighboring town of Seaside, so it's not particularly walkable.” 3
- “and yeah right off of community Road perfect location it's all about the location right guys” On camera63:28
- “Reply Apr 20th, 2002 | 07:10 AM #2 mary Guest Posts: n/a We enjoyed the Pacific Hotel in Monterey. We enjoyed the Pacific Hotel in Monterey. Lovely rooms with balconies. Easy walk to the warf.” 2
- “The result is modern, comfortable rooms that embrace the oceanfront location while still preserving much of the architecture's original retro charm.” 3
- “Though it's walking distance to the beach, the hotel's location across the freeway from the ocean makes for an awkward walk, and guests will need a car to reach other attractions.” 10
- “Cool little hotel right in the middle of downtown Monterey. Reasonably priced with great history.” 18
- “The rooms are beautifully furnished and very clean, the beds are extremely comfortable, and the location is quiet yet right downtown with excellent dining nearby.” 18
- “The little Otter Inn is about 2 blocks from the Aquarium and Cannery Row, is very reasonably priced and includes underground parking which is a big plus in Monterey.” 2
- “The bathroom was large and well lit with a nice shower that got hot fast.” 8
- “the bathroom is small but functional there isn't a lot of counter space so make sure you plan accordingly if you bring a lot of items with you there's only a shower no tub and the shower doesn't have a door so things will get wet if they're left right next to the opening” On camera93:01
- “In any case, the generous vanity area more than made up for it and made getting ready in the morning easy and comfortable.” 3
- “and then of course the shower shower is super important to all of us you want to have the space you want to have a nice shower head everything here is really really nice” On camera61:54
- “The shower and toilet area was a bit small, though still well-appointed with luxury bath amenities and a rain shower.” 3
- “Couples looking for quiet relaxation may want to look elsewhere, as weekends can get loud with families here enjoying the pools and outdoor activities.” 19
- “Outdoor fire pits are a fun feature, and the s'mores available in the lobby make them another magnet for kids. However, the boisterousness of the outdoor spaces added to rooms' thin walls can frustrate guests traveling without children.” 10
- “Wi-Fi at the hotel was hit-or-miss, and I heard multiple guests complaining about this during my stay.” 19
- “it's so nice man I think it's the sound of the ocean right there and not only that guys if you get an ocean view room you can literally hear hopefully you're not like a you know light sleep or whatever but you can hear the ocean waves all night it is so nice so nice” On camera2130:16
- “there's my robe from the spa really nice robes” On camera61:49
- “The staff was super nice and helpful.” 18
- “now they do have elevators and they do have steps as well so you don't necessarily have to take the elevators nice some hotels just have one or the other that I've been to in the past” On camera2125:26
- “Rooms at the Hyatt Regency Monterey Hotel & Spa are spacious and well appointed, if uninspired, despite a few nice design touches.” 10
- “Wi-Fi at the hotel was hit-or-miss, and I heard multiple guests complaining about this during my stay. However, the service was attentive and thorough, both with daily housekeeping and laundry services, which I utilized after taking advantage of the surprisingly good gym at the hotel.” 19
- “The service was genuinely friendly, and the food was delicious.” 3
- “The staff is kind and accommodating, and the off-season prices are very good.” 18
- “upon entering the hotel's main lobby you're greeted by the friendly faces of the wonderful staff at the registration desk” On camera90:28
- “The hotel looks austere, perhaps motel like from the outside, but I have always found the staff friendly, the rooms are comfortable with small balconies facing water.” 2
- “At the Red Lion Hotel Monterey, we combine attentive service with a comfortable, inviting atmosphere to ensure your stay is nothing short of memorable.” On camera221:49
- “Since we were gone most of the day exploring the area, we elected to valet park each night when we got to the hotel. It is a delightful experience as the car was always waiting for us when we needed it.” 8
- “Right in the middle of everything. They offered contactless check-in, which was quick and easy. Every hotel should have this.” 18
- “The staff was very friendly and accommodating. We plan on staying again.” 18
- “The food was well prepared and nicely presented, and the service was excellent, as always.” 17
- “Whether you are traveling for a much-needed vacation or a professional business trip, this three-star gem serves as the perfect base for exploring the stunning scenic coastlines and vibrant local attractions that make the Central Coast so iconic.” On camera220:21
- “The prices, I thought, were reasonable because the room was large and elegant, the staff friendly, and there was free parking.” 2
- “The staff was welcoming and friendly. We stayed four nights and will definitely be back.” 18
- “awesome I got some water it's always nice when they Supply water not every place does” On camera62:46
- “and then down there that is the shooter's restaurant on site very delicious a little water fountain there” On camera63:20
- “The included continental breakfast was a great addition to the hotel experience as it had lots of pastries and fresh bagels, as well as large bowls of fruit and coffee.” 8
- “The food was well prepared and nicely presented, and the service was excellent, as always.” 17
- “Save room for dessert, though - the bread pudding is generous and very good.” 3
- “one of the highlights of the hotel is the sea Roots breakfast buffet featuring a juicer where you make your own juice in addition to standard Buffet offerings such as charcuterie bagels cream cheese locks scrambled eggs breakfast potatoes bacon and sausage egg frittatas waffles oatmeal with various toppings yogurt fresh fruit pastries and various choices of bread” On camera90:59
- “The Victorian serves a nice breakfast in their lobby area (or you can take tray back to your room)” 2
What we still don't know
What we can’t tell you yet, said plainly. These close as we read more coverage of this hotel.
- No reviewer has named an individual room number here yet.
- Nothing reliable said about room types.
- Nothing reliable said about building or wing.
- Nothing reliable said about which side it faces.
- Nothing reliable said about position on the floor.
- 12 sources carry no publication date, so we cannot tell how current they are.
Ask about The Monterey Hotel
Answered only from the coverage cited on this page. If nobody has written about your question, it will say so rather than guess.
How much we read
Deep coverage · 61/100We read 23 sources for this property, and pulled 132 traveler insights worth knowing. Last checked 2026-09-13.
Watch this hotel
We keep reading The Monterey Hotel. Tell us when you're staying and we'll follow it until then — you'll hear from us only when the verdict is rewritten, the score moves, or new reviews land. No daily mail, and the watch closes itself after your stay.
Sources
Everything quoted on this page, grouped by traveler insights, outlets, and video & podcast. Counts beside each group show everything we’ve read of that kind; no one kind can carry the score on its own.
4 of 5 summary lines above are traced to specific quotes. The rest summarise the read as a whole rather than any single document.
View all 22 cited sources▾
Everything quoted on this page.
- 3An In-Depth Review of Monterey Beach Hotelwheresjessieb.comReview site2026-02-27Current11 quotes used
“The décor is coastal yet contemporary, with cozy touches like fireplaces in the social spaces and window-side lounge areas in the rooms that center around enjoying the nature just outside.”
Read originalwheresjessieb.com - 1
- 5Monterey Beach Hotel a Tribute Property. : r/marriottreddit.comForum thread2025-09-09Recent3 quotes used
“3rd floor beach view room that while had a beautiful view our room was very disappointing.”
Read originalreddit.com - 4What are the best hotels to stay in Monterey, CA?community.triphippies.comReview site2025-07-16RecentRead originalcommunity.triphippies.com
- 19What it's like staying at the Hyatt Regency Monterey Hotel ...thepointsguy.comReview site2024-12-04Ageing12 quotes used
“If you're looking to be in the heart of Monterey or on the ocean, the Hyatt's secluded golf course location might not be on the top of your list.”
Read originalthepointsguy.com - 10Hyatt Regency Monterey Hotel and Spa on Del Monte Golf ...oyster.comReview site2024-08-11Ageing18 quotes used
“Convenient location a short drive to Monterey attractions and restaurants”
Read originaloyster.com
More in Monterey
All Monterey hotels →A central Monterey stay offering comfortable beds, friendly staff, and easy downtown dining access.
A Spanish-style Monterey hotel with plush bedding, on-site tapas at Estéban, and walkable access to downtown.
A clean, budget-friendly downtown Monterey stay with helpful front desk staff and convenient lobby refreshments.
A roadside Monterey base with free parking, complimentary breakfast, and rooms featuring balconies with water views.
Remodeled rooms with golf course views and free parking just minutes by car from downtown Monterey.