$$
Buffalo Mountain Lodge
A peaceful Tunnel Mountain lodge featuring wood-burning fireplaces, clawfoot tubs, and mountain views.
Strong · Deep coverage · read from 21 sources · 117 traveler insights
80
RoomExpert Score
Strong
The verdict
Who's travelling?
Pick a traveller type to re-weight the scores and re-rank the rooms around what you actually care about.
Read it your way
Buffalo Mountain Lodge offers a quiet retreat on the slopes of Tunnel Mountain, just outside the bustle of downtown Banff. Accommodations feature rustic comforts like wood-burning fireplaces, clawfoot bathtubs, and private balconies in the trees. Guests consistently praise the on-site dining for hearty meals such as salmon and butternut squash ravioli. However, the rooms lack air conditioning, leaving guests hot and poorly rested on warm nights even when using fans. 1216202
Every line below traces back to something a traveler actually wrote — open a line to read the original sentence and follow it to the source.
What travelers noticed
- Reviewers consistently praise the in-room amenities, especially the wood-burning fireplaces, comfortable beds, and clawfoot bathtubs. 12
- The lodge maintains a quiet atmosphere on Tunnel Mountain Road, surrounded by trees and chirping birds. 21216
- Dining is a highlight across reviews, with guests noting standout dishes like butternut squash ravioli and salmon. 12
The catch
- While some guests enjoy private balconies with views of Cascade Mountain and the Bow Valley, others note their rooms lack mountain views entirely. 7162
- Some travelers love staying away from the busy downtown crowds, but others find the property less convenient because it is not right in town for walking. 127
Who it's for
- — Travelers wanting in-room wood-burning fireplaces
- — Guests seeking a quiet retreat away from Banff Avenue
- — Diners interested in on-site Canadian Rockies cuisine
Skip it if
- — Warm-weather travelers who need air conditioning
- — Guests wanting direct walkability to downtown Banff
- — Anyone unable to manage luggage on stairs without an elevator
How to book
Cash stay
No loyalty currency of its own — this one is a cash or card-portal booking.
Book with us
Score breakdown
How the 80/100 is built, category by category — each one with the strongest thing travelers actually said, and the source it came from.
Bathroom
81read from 1 source · Deep coverage
- “The best part of the Premier Rooms are the spacious bathrooms stocked with L'Occitane products which featured both a separate shower stall and an old fashioned claw-footed bathtub, perfect for decompressing from the cold.” 5
- “The bathrooms are much nicer than Rimrock - soaking tubs for cold plunge or hot bath, dimmable lights, large vanity and separate fan.” 20
Food
90read from 10 sources · Solid coverage
- “Even if you don't decide to stay at Buffalo Mountain Lodge, I would highly recommend booking a dinner reservation for their Sleeping Buffalo Restaurant and Lounge - I was blown away by how delicious our meal was!” 5
- “Yes, we've already mentioned how great the food is, but seriously, the Sleeping Buffalo restaurant is one you don't want to miss if you're a foodie. The menu is about as Canadian as you can get, with unique meats like Caribou and Bison as well as some of the most incredible gelato I've ever had.” 15
Location
86read from 1 source · Deep coverage
- “just a 15-minute walk or a three-minute drive from the shopping nightlife and restaurants in downtown banff is a hidden gem situated on tunnel mountain is the buffalo mountain lodge a peaceful mountain retreat surrounded by nine acres of wilderness it makes an excellent base camp for hiking skiing and wildlife” 16
- “I just stayed at Peaks in September. It's SO walkable to everything in town. We also walked to the Tunnel Mountain trailhead.” 11
Noise
91read from 4 sources · Solid coverage
- “rimrock hands down: far away from the packed town to wind down but close enough to get to the hot spots easily. hot springs across the street, gondola just up the street. and you're on the side of mountain, how cool is that.” 20
- “rimrock hands down: far away from the packed town to wind down but close enough to get to the hot spots easily. hot springs across the street, gondola just up the street.” 20
Room
79read from 1 source · Deep coverage
- “Most notable are the views from the mountain view rooms that look out to Cascade Mountain. Our room 902 had an incredible porch view across the Bow Valley, where we appreciated a morning coffee or evening drink.” 7
- “I had my wedding reception at Buffalo Mountain Lodge and highly recommend it. The suites are beautiful and if you don't have a room with a view (some do, some don't), a quick walk over to Tunnel Mountain Reservoir across the street will give you an incredible view.” 11
Service
83read from 1 source · Deep coverage
Bed & Sleep
81read from 1 source · Deep coverage
- “We found the bed and bedding to be comfortable, which made for a good night's sleep, especially given the property's quiet location. The king-size bed was much appreciated, as, surprisingly, you can't always get a king in the Rockies.” 7
Value
74read from 1 source · Deep coverage
- “The other reason is the hotel's wonderful "Pasta Monday" deal in the shoulder and off season months. It has various pastas for around $14 a plate and deals on drinks such as cocktails, wine, and beer - an absolute steal in Banff!” 7
- “Nothing in Banff is cheap and prices vary widely throughout the season. That said it pays to book the right room category in advance, Buffalo Mountain Lodge can offer great value-especially when you compare to some of the "luxury" hotels in town.” 7
Where it is, how to reach it
700 Tunnel Mountain Road
Banff, Banff National Park
T1L 1B3 Canada
Details checked 2026-09-13
Where it sits
Buffalo Mountain Lodge and the 23 other hotels we cover in Banff. Hover a marker for the hotel; click to open it.
Stay value
How this property reads against the hotels we cover alongside it. Measured on review evidence, not on a nightly rate.
Trails its peers
Falls short of what $$ usually buys
Scores 6 points below the mid-range median of 86, across 791 hotels in the same bracket. In Banff it sits 4 points below the local median of 84.
Price bracket
$$
Mid-range
- This hotel
- 80
- Bracket median
- 86
- Index median
- 86
Based on 791 comparable hotels.
Which room to ask for
What reviewers say about where to sleep inside this building — by room number where one is named, and otherwise by floor, wing, aspect and position. Every line opens onto the quotes behind it.
Ask for
- 5 mentions
- 3 mentions
- 1 mention
- 1 mention
Avoid
No location within the hotel draws repeated complaints yet.
Where travelers agree — and don’t
The topics reviewers split on most. A wide bar means your experience depends on which room you get — or whose opinion you trust.
Value
70
Food
63
Noise
53
Location
42
Room
41
Service
35
Bathroom
10
View the 80 things travelers said behind this verdict▾
Quotes run exactly as travelers wrote them — spelling and all. We trim for length, never for tidiness.
Bed & Sleep1 mention
- “We found the bed and bedding to be comfortable, which made for a good night's sleep, especially given the property's quiet location. The king-size bed was much appreciated, as, surprisingly, you can't always get a king in the Rockies.” 7
Value6 mentions
- “Nothing in Banff is cheap and prices vary widely throughout the season. That said it pays to book the right room category in advance, Buffalo Mountain Lodge can offer great value-especially when you compare to some of the "luxury" hotels in town.” 7
- “Rimrock is "newer" and arguably more "luxurious" but it is expensive and you don't really get bang for your buck aside from nice restaurants and a great view (that you can see for free on foot by walking around the back of the hotel).” 20
- “I worked at the Banff springs for years (this would be the best option but it's not cheap...especially in December)” 11
- “The other reason is the hotel's wonderful "Pasta Monday" deal in the shoulder and off season months. It has various pastas for around $14 a plate and deals on drinks such as cocktails, wine, and beer - an absolute steal in Banff!” 7
- “I stayed there a couple weeks ago. We had a private hot tub room which was really pricey, but views were great.” 11
- “Located about 15 min from the Lake Louise turn off, but on highway 1A (the Bow Valley Parkway). Might cost you a bit more. So so worth it.” 20
Location11 mentions
- “We stayed at the Brewster a few years ago and it was only about 1 block from town and within walking distance of Banff Springs Lodge if your if good shape. The hotel was clean and seemed brand new at the time.” 4
- “just a 15-minute walk or a three-minute drive from the shopping nightlife and restaurants in downtown banff is a hidden gem situated on tunnel mountain is the buffalo mountain lodge a peaceful mountain retreat surrounded by nine acres of wilderness it makes an excellent base camp for hiking skiing and wildlife” 16
- “buffalo is in a nice location - a short walk/drive to town but not in the hecticness of the town and there is a little store & liquor store close by.” 4
- “The location was great though. The downtown area is super walkable and there is a bus that goes to the further points of interest” 11
- “You'll find the lodge on Tunnel Mountain Road, about three minutes by car from the main street in Banff, tucked into a grove of trees in the mountains. We both loved the location away from the hustle of bustle of the downtown. Yet, if you were to walk into town, it would only take about 15 minutes.” 12
- “I just stayed at Peaks in September. It's SO walkable to everything in town. We also walked to the Tunnel Mountain trailhead.” 11
- “I like the fact the lodge isn't too big, the parking is free, rooms are amazing, and the location is first-rate.” 12
- “Away from the tourist crowds yet conveniently situated within short driving distance to Banff's major attractions, this rustic hotel is the ideal location to situate yourself during a trip to Banff and its surrounding national parks.” 5
- “The makeup mirror goes on automatically if it senses a face nearby, which at night was annoying.” 20
- “I just stayed at Peaks in September. It's SO walkable to everything in town.” 11
- “buffalo is in a great location - up above the town so not as congested.” 4
Noise5 mentions
- “rimrock hands down: far away from the packed town to wind down but close enough to get to the hot spots easily. hot springs across the street, gondola just up the street. and you're on the side of mountain, how cool is that.” 20
- “If you are a light sleeper like I am, you might here train horns at night. We stayed at Moose for 2 nights, and both nights I heard the horns.” 11
- “rimrock hands down: far away from the packed town to wind down but close enough to get to the hot spots easily. hot springs across the street, gondola just up the street.” 20
- “We also appreciated the private balcony and opening windows. You won't hear much noise, other than birds chirping, when you curl up with a glass of wine and a good book on your own private balcony either.” 12
- “Buffalo Mountain Lodge is situated on the Tunnel Mountain slope and has a generally quiet atmosphere, save a few cars that drive by out front.” 2
Service11 mentions
- “The staff are also very friendly.” 11
- “Another thing I like about BML is you can drive there right off the highway via Tunnel Mountain Road and avoid the chaos of driving on Banff Avenue. The staff are also very friendly.” 11
- “The communal hot tubs were really nice as well with really pretty views.” 11
- “Nice that it's not busy like up at Louise. But you're still so close so can get up there early in the morning without it being a huge effort. (You're ten minutes from the L.L. ski area where the shuttle buses are)” 20
- “My husband and I stayed at Moose and it was a great hotel. Comfortable bed, clean room, nice staff.” 11
- “Going for a stroll is not what one does up at the Rimrock. It does have big views and good service.” 20
- “Nice that it's not busy like up at Louise. But you're still so close so can get up there early in the morning without it being a huge effort.” 20
- “Service is a little lacking but didn't take away from our experience.” 20
- “The staff were very helpful informing us what amenities were available and offering assistance in the absence of housekeeping” 16
- “Lastly, what you want a hotel like this for is the service, and I will say everyone was very kind.” 20
- “check-in was simple as we had reserved on the mrsr website in advance” 16
Food21 mentions
- “Breakfast isn't included. We didn't really enjoy the breakfast at Panini so I recommend going elsewhere. I believe Panini is the restaurant attached to Moose.” 11
- “We booked four excursions/experiences through them and we received wrong times and information about three of them. We also struggled with organizing dinner reservations, and transportation through them - very confusing communication. It all worked out, but it was exasperating, stressful and time consuming.” 20
- “The chef behind Buffalo Mountain Lodge's Sleeping Buffalo Dining Room coined Canadian Rockies cuisine and the restaurant is known for having excellent exotic dishes.” 2
- “It's fantastic as a real 'Canadian' experience. They have great custom-blend coffee from a roaster /shop in Banff.” 20
- “the buffalo mountain cafe was open for takeout and we enjoyed the breakfast sandwiches lattes and other dining options there daily” 16
- “Yes, we've already mentioned how great the food is, but seriously, the Sleeping Buffalo restaurant is one you don't want to miss if you're a foodie. The menu is about as Canadian as you can get, with unique meats like Caribou and Bison as well as some of the most incredible gelato I've ever had.” 15
- “For breakfast you can do a continental buffet, full buffet, or choose à la carte from the menu. It's standard fare - but served with a big dose of genuine friendliness.” 12
- “The hotel's on-site restaurant, The Prow, is a standout amenity. It offers some wonderful dishes throughout the day in a lovely environment.” 7
- “The Prow restaurant is great for any meal. Service is a little lacking but didn't take away from our experience.” 20
- “The excellent restaurant, which invented Canadian Rockies cuisine, is known for its wine list and exotic game dishes -- even at breakfast.” 2
- “Even if you don't decide to stay at Buffalo Mountain Lodge, I would highly recommend booking a dinner reservation for their Sleeping Buffalo Restaurant and Lounge - I was blown away by how delicious our meal was!” 5
- “The Prow restaurant at the lodge is really good and they have amazing cocktails. I've never had a bad meal at BML.” 11
- “If you're looking for something vegan/gluten free, I would say the dining here isn't your best option but it's definitely worth it for a treat.” 5
- “I've stayed at the Rimrock a few times. Great place, make sure to request a mountain view room. Nice rooms, great buffet breakfast.” 17
- “We spent one night at the Buffalo MOuntain Inn in a standard/e.g.deluxe room. We were very happy with it. Fireplace was wonderful and everything about it was fine. By the way, their dining room serves an excellent breakfast.” 4
- “Few-Grapefruit-3620 • 3mo ago staying there as well for 5 nights...thanks Spute2008 • 3mo ago It's fantastic as a real 'Canadian' experience. They have great custom-blend coffee from a roaster /shop in Banff.” 20
- “We booked four excursions/experiences through them and we received wrong times and information about three of them. We also struggled with organizing dinner reservations, and transportation through them - very confusing communication.” 20
- “For breakfast the next morning, I treated myself to the Mountain Granola which was more like desert (whoops) but SO tasty.” 5
- “The Prow restaurant is great for any meal.” 20
- “The other is the quintessential mountain lodge with great food, deer roaming the grounds and the feeling you're in nature.” 20
- “For dinner we ordered up the Artisan Salad and Seared Scallops as an appetizer and then finished it off with the Pacific Halibut which was filling and flavorful.” 5
Room20 mentions
- “The only thing I think that needs a little work at Buffalo Mountain Lodge - and my sister-in-law concurred, is the room lighting. Even with all the lights on, it's a bit dark.” 12
- “The other party with us did have a small balcony but said it wasn't particularly inviting.” 20
- “The makeup mirror goes on automatically if it senses a face nearby, which at night was annoying. Our room didn't have outdoor access, but a great view.” 20
- “The interiors mix modern furniture with natural materials that retain the property's original character. This made for a modern stay that still gave us those old-school Banff vibes we love.” 7
- “I've stayed at Banff Aspen and had a great time. I had a nice balcony with a view of Banff Ave.” 11
- “The Suite was large too, it's a full one bedroom with a kitchenette.” 11
- “Nice decor touches, great beds. Nice that it's not busy like up at Louise.” 20
- “Most notable are the views from the mountain view rooms that look out to Cascade Mountain. Our room 902 had an incredible porch view across the Bow Valley, where we appreciated a morning coffee or evening drink.” 7
- “Maybe somehwat dark, but it did not realy matter to me (we were out skiing all day). Our room had a great fireplace, spacious bathroom, and a balcony.” 17
- “Nice decor touches, great beds.” 20
- “Commenting on the room we stayed in so may be different- The bathrooms are much nicer than Rimrock - soaking tubs for cold plunge or hot bath, dimmable lights, large vanity and separate fan. Our room had a lovely private balcony in the trees.” 20
- “I had my wedding reception at Buffalo Mountain Lodge and highly recommend it. The suites are beautiful and if you don't have a room with a view (some do, some don't), a quick walk over to Tunnel Mountain Reservoir across the street will give you an incredible view.” 11
- “Throwing open our door to our room we were greeted with a couple of comfortable chairs around a wood-burning fireplace, two queen-sized beds, a desk and chair as well as an over-sized bathroom, complete with a soaker tub and shower. We also appreciated the private balcony and opening windows.” 12
- “Our room had a lovely private balcony in the trees. There is no elevator, so if bringing luggage upstairs is a problem, may want to request a ground floor room.” 20
- “My husband and I stayed at Moose and it was a great hotel. Comfortable bed, clean room, nice staff.” 11
- “The suites are beautiful and if you don't have a room with a view (some do, some don't), a quick walk over to Tunnel Mountain Reservoir across the street will give you an incredible view.” 11
- “<BR> Reply Sep 1st, 2002 | 07:01 PM #6 Andrea Guest Posts: n/a Just got back from a wonderful trip to Canadian Rockies. We spent one night at the Buffalo MOuntain Inn in a standard/e.g.deluxe room. We were very happy with it.” 4
- “there was lots of space and with a pull out bed in the living room would comfortably sleep four people” 16
- “We also walked to the Tunnel Mountain trailhead. We stayed in the Summit Grand King Suite with Balcony and had a small view of mountains with fire pit outside. The Suite was large too, it's a full one bedroom with a kitchenette.” 11
- “Few-Grapefruit-3620 • 3mo ago staying there as well for 5 nights...thanks Spute2008 • 3mo ago It's fantastic as a real 'Canadian' experience. They have great custom-blend coffee from a roaster /shop in Banff. Nice decor touches, great beds.” 20
Bathroom5 mentions
- “The bathrooms are much nicer than Rimrock - soaking tubs for cold plunge or hot bath, dimmable lights, large vanity and separate fan.” 20
- “Ok well maybe you don't have to be a Victoria to bathe like this, but the clawfoot bathtub in the room was something very unusual to come across.” 15
- “Commenting on the room we stayed in so may be different- The bathrooms are much nicer than Rimrock - soaking tubs for cold plunge or hot bath, dimmable lights, large vanity and separate fan.” 20
- “each room has a private bathroom complete with towels toiletries and hair dryer ours was modest but clean and bright with shower and good water pressure” 16
- “The best part of the Premier Rooms are the spacious bathrooms stocked with L'Occitane products which featured both a separate shower stall and an old fashioned claw-footed bathtub, perfect for decompressing from the cold.” 5
What we still don't know
What we can’t tell you yet, said plainly. These close as we read more coverage of this hotel.
- Nothing reliable said about room types.
- Nothing reliable said about building or wing.
- Nothing reliable said about position on the floor.
- 12 sources carry no publication date, so we cannot tell how current they are.
Ask about Buffalo Mountain Lodge
Answered only from the coverage cited on this page. If nobody has written about your question, it will say so rather than guess.
How much we read
Deep coverage · 56/100We read 21 sources for this property, and pulled 117 traveler insights worth knowing. Last checked 2026-09-13.
0
Editorial
20
Blogs & sites
1
Video reviews
0
Podcast segments
Breadth
38
Depth
52
Freshness
96
Watch this hotel
We keep reading Buffalo Mountain Lodge. Tell us when you're staying and we'll follow it until then — you'll hear from us only when the verdict is rewritten, the score moves, or new reviews land. No daily mail, and the watch closes itself after your stay.
Sources
Everything quoted on this page, grouped by traveler insights, outlets, and video & podcast. Counts beside each group show everything we’ve read of that kind; no one kind can carry the score on its own.
5 of 5 summary lines above are traced to specific quotes. The rest summarise the read as a whole rather than any single document.
View all 21 cited sources▾
Everything quoted on this page.
- 20Locals, settle this: Buffalo Mountain Lodge or Rimrock? I'm ...reddit.comForum thread2026-06-13Current37 quotes used
“Nice decor touches, great beds.”
Read originalreddit.com - 3
- 11Best Hotel in Banff: Moose, Aspen Lodge, Peaks, Buffalo ...reddit.comForum thread2024-11-04Ageing28 quotes used
“The staff are also very friendly.”
Read originalreddit.com - 2Buffalo Mountain Lodge Review - Banffoyster.comReview site2024-08-11Ageing7 quotes used
“There's no AC and even with fans the rooms can get stuffy in the summertime, though most have balconies or patios that help circulate fresh air.”
Read originaloyster.com - 18Buffalo Mountain Lodge | Accommodations & Suitescrmr.comReview site2021-02-03AgeingRead originalcrmr.com
- 14Buffalo Mountain Lodge Banff | Hotel and Lodge in Banff, ABcrmr.comReview site2021-01-29AgeingRead originalcrmr.com
Showing 6 of 21 cited · 21 read
1/4
More in Banff
All Banff hotels →Baker Creek By Basecamp
$$
Rustic cabins and jacuzzi suites along the Bow Valley Parkway, 15 minutes from Lake Louise.
Banff Aspen Lodge
$
A Banff Avenue ski lodge featuring courtyard outdoor hot tubs, hearty free breakfast, and exceptionally comfortable beds.
Banff Caribou Lodge & Spa
$
A Banff Avenue mountain lodge featuring rooftop hot tubs, an on-site steakhouse, and ski shuttle pick-up.
Banff Park Lodge Resort Hotel & Conference Centre
$
Downtown Banff lodge offering spacious balcony rooms, comfortable beds, and easy walking access to shops and dining.
Best Western Plus Banff International Lodge
$$
A centrally located Banff lodge featuring glass showers, heated bathroom floors, and an on-site Chili's.
Blackstone Mountain Lodge
$$
A quiet lodge offering spacious suites, exceptionally comfortable beds, and heated pool mountain views.
Browse hotels like this